Protesters Show Up and Show Out in Salem

—

7–10 minutes

“These people decry government overreach as they try to use the government to dictate what citizens can and cannot read.”

– Amanda Jones, That Librarian, The Fight Against Book Banning in America.

We have focused on multiple stories of book banning in libraries and for a good reason. Democracy begins and ends with the ability of its citizens to be well-informed and have access to a variety of voices and viewpoints that shape how they think and what they believe.

Our stories across the state showcase a rising tension between those who believe in equal access to materials, regardless of viewpoint, and those that believe they have the right to tell others what they can and cannot access.

Throughout history, we have seen numerous examples of countries that allowed their books to be banned or burned and what that led to with its people. As librarians and library workers, it is our duty to keep fighting for everyone’s access so these events do not occur here.

We are doing our best to hold that line, along with our patrons. This deserves to be spotlighted and we will continue to do so.

However, the library isn’t just fighting against book bans. Libraries are, and have always been, a place where communities gather to continue the democratic tradition in a variety of ways. 

Many libraries serve as polling places during elections. Libraries will host informational sessions to teach patrons how they can vote. (Note: libraries do not tell patrons WHO to vote for, despite the rumors. We teach people where they can vote, what the process looks like, why it’s important to vote, etc.).

Libraries also allow those in the community to book spaces where groups and speakers can come and have informational sessions themselves. Most libraries use the rule that as long as the event is free, open to the public, and no one is selling anything, then any group is welcome to book the space. This allows libraries to continue being neutral spaces for everyone.

This has led to numerous political groups booking spaces in libraries in order to reach the constituents who frequent those libraries. Most of the time, it’s fine. The group comes, they have their meeting, and they leave. No issues, right?

Notice I said most of the time. In our story today, one of those situations occurred and went sideways fairly quickly.

We travel today to Winston-Salem and Forsyth County to see what occurred at the library on August 29.

Forsyth County is the fourth largest county in our state and home to the fourth largest library system. Its most notable city is Winston-Salem, home to Old Salem, which is a fun place to visit if you find yourself nearby. 

The Central Library of the Forsyth County Public Library system is a newer construction, built in 2017, and covering a whopping 100,000+ square feet in downtown Winston-Salem. It’s a truly beautiful building and features many unique spaces for the public to access. 

One of those spaces is a large auditorium that can seat around 200 people. From what I could find, it gets used fairly often for a variety of reasons, and is appreciated in the community as a great space for events and meetings. 

One group had apparently thought the same and booked the space for an informational meeting. This group was the Democratic Socialists of America. They went through the process of booking the space for Saturday, August 29, 2026.

As part of their meeting, they had done their own marketing to garner interest in the event.

Marketing that apparently traveled quite a ways to the coast and the Cape Fear chapter of the Proud Boys.

On that Saturday, the Democratic Socialists group began their meeting at the scheduled time of 1:30 p.m. Shortly after, some of the Proud Boys set up outside of the library, on the library’s front lawn. They stayed clear of the door and were not making any noises, but had planted their flag and were standing facing all the patrons who entered the library in a clear move of intimidation. 

While some of the group remained outside, some of the group went inside to try and enter the meeting. They were stopped at the door by some of the meeting attendees, who then proceeded to block the doors and deny entry to the Proud Boys. 

The issue with that stems from the language that most libraries use in their policies, and this one is no different. All meetings in the public spaces MUST be free and open to the public. 

The Proud Boys then began harassing security to allow them into the meeting, to which security informed the Socialists they had to let the other group in. The Proud Boys were warned however not to make trouble or they would be escorted out. The group went into the meeting and sat quietly in the back while the meeting took place. 

Meanwhile, there were still quite a few Proud boys outside the library, quietly protesting. 

This led to many in the community standing outside of the library on the sidewalks, counter-protesting the Proud Boys. Chants of “Go home, Fascists” and “Kill the pedophiles” were heard and reported from the counter-protesters. 

Police were called, though because no violence was reported, they simply stayed and monitored the situation for any potential issues. 

The entire situation seems to have lasted for a couple of hours, until the meeting of the Democratic Socialists was called to an end. At that point, all parties disbanded and the library went back to normal operations. 

I did speak with one anonymous source who had this to say,

“I was very disappointed in everyone in this instance. I was working at the time and saw many patrons leave in fear because of the tension in the air. Children were crying, people were shouting, some people were filming, one of the guys had a megaphone that you could hear in the library…it was chaotic and disturbed everyone in the library. It never should have happened.”

From all the reports I could find, it seems that nothing was done to try and break up the protest at any point. I did find reports that praise the counter-protesters for fighting the Proud Boys. 

However, I would like to add my own voice here and say that many mistakes were made from what I have found. 

First, the group holding the meeting should have known that they could not bar access to their meeting based on the policies they signed. As much as they disagreed with the group trying to get in, they still cannot stop them from coming in. Quite frankly, if they did go in and make trouble, that could only have been to the benefit of the Democratic Socialists because then the group would have been removed from the library under legitimate grounds.

Second, the Proud Boys should never have come to a library filled with patrons of all ages and backgrounds to protest a group that had nothing to do with them. They traveled hundreds of miles just to cause trouble, which they knew would happen, regardless of their own behaviors. Libraries are not the place to cause trouble when people are there to do work or spend time with family.

Third, the fact that people were allowed to stand outside the library causing disruptions to the patronage of the library, is disturbing. We all work in libraries and know that people use the space for various reasons. Maybe they are putting in applications, or studying, or tutoring, or searching for materials, or trying to find a safe space to be while waiting for shelters to open. In this case, every single person in the library was disturbed, and according to my source, people were leaving in fear. Why was this allowed to continue?

Our own personal beliefs and biases have no place in libraries. All librarians and library workers know that we have opinions as much as anyone. However, we do not let that stop us from offering materials and spaces that are for everyone. Whether or not you agree with the message from either group, the whole situation was unfortunate.

In a way, we can see democracy at work here as the right to peaceful protest is a right guaranteed to us in our constitution. However, we also see that the purpose of the Proud Boys was to cause disruption and chaos, not to speak out in protest of what the Democratic Socialists were trying to say in their meeting. And at the end of the day, they got what they wanted by having all the media coverage and the reaction of the community.

We know that libraries will continue to be a place in the spotlight leading up to election season. We know that we are a talking point for politicians on every side and we are very much in the public eye right now. Situations like the one above will more than likely continue to happen in the future. 

It is our job to continue being a space that provides information and safety for our patrons. May we all find a way to navigate this harsh landscape during this time of turmoil and confusion. 

If you have not heard it yet today, thank you for all you do for your community!

Resources:

https://journalnow.com/news/local/government-politics/article_6ac75df4-235e-43c2-86f8-9e5a654567dd.html

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omo6xf16LsU

https://hickoryrecord.com/video/news/video_bd0838bb-e74f-55c1-912d-1806eee165ec.html

https://journalnow.com/news/local/column/article_64dc15ed-f611-461f-b9ea-a95e06dc2a33.html

1