“If somebody is telling you there is one history, one people & one version of events, you should consider what side of history that they’re on.”
– Sara Ellie MacKenzie
This year marked a historic election in numerous ways. We saw a blue wave sweep across the states in a way that hasn’t occurred in decades. Many historically Republican seats in all areas of Congress, as well as some Gubernatorial races, flipped and will welcome a Democratic nominee in the months to come.
We saw several races that elected a historically underserved member of the population to a seat, including the first ever female Native-American, and the first female African-American, elected as governors of New Mexico and Georgia respectively. There were also numerous members of the LGBTQIA+ community elected across the states for various roles.


While this is exciting news for the country as a whole, we also saw history made closer to home. North Carolina has been an openly red state for decades, often electing a Democrat as governor, but keeping the Republican majority in the House and Senate. This election saw Democrats take back enough seats to gain the majority in the House and break the Republican supermajority in the Senate.
This could mean many things moving forward for our state, as well as our country.
One thing we of course are looking at is what this will mean for book bans.
Republicans have been able to put forth bills across the country for years now that have targeted print and digital resources featuring peoples and themes they disagree with. This has largely featured materials dealing with themes of race, ethnicity, culture, history, sexuality, and gender-identity.
In NC alone, there have been numerous bills that have either passed, or are currently being reviewed, that limit access to these materials for students.
There are many reasons we could put forth as to why books have been such a hot button issue, gaining traction in their controversy over the past decade.
One potential reason is because having people focus on smaller issues like a book having a side character who happens to be gay, distracts from the larger issues and allows those in power to adjust wording in certain laws to make gains negatively affecting large swaths of the population.
But that is just a guess…

However, the plan worked and people have been fighting over the Right to Read and access information for several years, to the point where laws have been passed dictating what books can be shared in a library and what books cannot.
We have discussed in quite a bit of detail Senate Bill 49, otherwise known as the Parents’ Bill of Rights. This bill changed the landscape of how schools and parents dealt with book challenges, as well as topics like gender-identity, for North Carolina.
We have seen the effects it can have on individual people, but we have also seen the effects of what it can do to schools. When a school, or school official, is faced with the potential of being punished for not adhering to an arbitrary law, they will often overcompensate and drastically reduce the amount of access students have to materials.
It has been increasingly frustrating to watch naturally curious students be limited in what ideas and opinions they can pursue because some people disagree with certain topics.
We have also discussed HB 636 and 595, both of which would also limit access to materials and dictate what teachers and librarians can do in their classrooms and libraries.
However, one bill we have not touched on is HB 1043. This bill is currently showing as “in committee” and would outright ban any materials from school libraries that feature topics or characters dealing with LGBTQIA+ issues. It expands on Senate Bill 49, which only covered “supplementary materials” for the purpose of instruction in grades K-4th. However, this bill uses language that includes “Electronic, print, or non-print resource[s] for independent use by students and school personnel and not used as part of the standard course of study for any grade or course, whether held in a formal school library or in a classroom” (access the bill to read more).
These are the kinds of bills being passed in various states and they have long-lasting impacts on the students who are growing up with no access to materials that represent who they are, or who their families are. They are also growing up without access to materials that grow their empathy and understanding, creating a population who will lack the ability to connect with one another and build trust and community.
At the time of this writing, bills such as HB 1043 will likely not be made into law as it was introduced in a session that has concluded. There have been quite a few bills introduced that are not moving forward at this time. However, I still believe it is important to highlight these as an example of the way in which libraries, and books, are being used as talking points and not so vague threats.
This has all been troubling to watch and deal with for the past decade that these issues have ramped up. But the election this month that saw so many Democrats being elected could mean a shift away from small button issues such as book bans.

The Democratic Party has historically been against book banning. Indeed, there is an NC bill, also currently showing as “in committee” and unlikely to move forward, proposed by Democrats called HB 902, or the Free to Learn – Library Bill of Rights Act, which would create protections for library users against discrimination and privacy violations.
It is impossible to know what the coming months and years will mean in terms of book banning, or libraries in general. The election does give us reason to hope as we move forward. There are states where laws have passed prohibiting book banning, or severely limiting who can bring forth challenges and why. We can certainly hope that these become more commonplace for everyone.
We here at Read Free NC will continue to keep an eye on the state and the changes brought forth by those in elected positions of power. Our website has a bill tracker under the “Get Involved” tab where you can see which bills have passed, which have failed, and which are being discussed. There are also many ways to get involved and help guide change and positivity in your community.
If you have any questions or need help with where to get started, reach out to us. We have volunteers who can help guide you toward resources that will assist you in your fight.
As always, if you have not heard it yet today, thank you for all you do for your community!
